NY top court says 'private' Facebook photos can be disclosed [Tribune] 14 Feb, 2018

A picture illustration shows a Facebook logo reflected in a person's eye, in Zenica, March 13, 2015.PHOTO: REUTERS New York state’s highest court ruled on Tuesday that Facebook users may be required to turn over photos and other information that is relevant to litigation, even if they are shielded by “privacy” settings.By a 7-0 vote, the Court of Appeals reinstated a trial judge’s ruling requiring a Manhattan woman who was disabled in a horse riding accident to turn over to the defendant horse owner an array of photos taken before and after her injuries.Noting “significant controversy” over what information on Facebook deserves privacy protection, Chief Judge Janet DiFiore said it is appropriate to require disclosure of materials that are “reasonably calculated” to contain “material and necessary” evidence.Less-cool Facebook losing youth at fast paceKelly Forman said she became a recluse after suffering a spinal injury and brain damage, making it hard to read and write, in a June 2011 fall caused by Mark Henkin’s negligence in fitting her horse with a defective stirrup that broke.To defend himself against Forman’s damages claims, Henkin sought access to her entire “private” Facebook account.In February 2014, a trial judge ordered Forman to give Henkin pre-accident photos she intended to use at trial, post-accident photos not depicting nudity or romantic encounters, and access to post-accident records of her messages.But in December 2015, a state appeals court limited the disclosure to photos intended for trial, saying Henkin could not go on a “fishing expedition” for evidence.Facebook to promote local news in latest updateDiFiore, however, reinstated the trial judge’s ruling, saying the appeals court erred in employing a “heightened threshold” for disclosing social media records that depended on what users chose to share publicly.“Some materials on a Facebook account may fairly be characterized as private,” DiFiore wrote, “but even private materials may be subject to discovery if they are relevant.”Henkin’s photo request “was reasonably calculated to yield evidence relevant to plaintiff’s assertion that she could no longer engage in the activities she enjoyed before the accident and that she had become reclusive,” she added.Forman’s lawyer had no immediate comment. Henkin’s lawyer did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

More News

Japanese scientists invent floating 'firefly' light

23 Feb, 2018 Tribune

ERATO Kawahara Universal Information Network Project's 'Luciola', miniature floating LED light aptly named after fireflies, drawing the ... Detail

China's Huawei set to lead global charge to 5G networks

23 Feb, 2018 Tribune

A man walks past a logo during the presentation the Huawei's new smartphone, the Ascend P7, launched by China's Huawei Technologies in Paris ... Detail

Wait, I know you: home security startup taps face-recognition tech

23 Feb, 2018 Tribune

Lighthouse AI, 3D sensor-based camera that can recognize individual faces appears in this undated handout photo provided on February 22, 2018.PHOTO: R ... Detail

Mexico's Televisa to create content for Amazon Prime

23 Feb, 2018 Tribune

The logo of broadcaster Televisa is pictured at a truck in Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, November 16, 2017.PHOTO: REUTERS Mexican broadcaster Televisa said o ... Detail

Dots in Gmail addresses not as important as you think

23 Feb, 2018 Tribune

A Google search page is reflected in sunglasses in this photo illustration taken in Brussels May 30, 2014. PHOTO: REUTERS There’s always been a lot of ... Detail

Post Your Comments
Type your Comments / Review in the space below.
Verify Code