LHC slaps ban on airing of ‘anti-judiciary’ speeches by Nawaz, Maryam, PM [DailyTimes] 17 Apr, 2018

The Lahore High Court (LHC) on Monday slapped a temporary ban on airing of ‘anti-judiciary’ speeches by former prime minister Nawaz Sharif, his daughter Maryam Nawaz, Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi and other leaders of the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N).A full bench of the high court headed by Justice Mazahir Ali Akbar Naqvi and comprising Justice Masood Jahangir and Justice Atir Mahmoud resumed hearing of 27 miscellaneous contempt petitions. The court referred the petitions to the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA), granting it 15 days to remove all anti-judiciary content in addition to deciding on the petitions.Justice Mazahir Ali Naqvi ruled that the court will personally monitor PEMRA’s conduct in the next two weeks to see how it implements the court order. The high court also directed all authorities concerned to ensure that no contemptuous speech is broadcast on any TV channel in the next 15 days.During the proceedings, the PEMRA was criticized for dismissing petitions highlighting ‘anti-judiciary’ remarks. The counsel for the petitioners informed the court that PEMRA did not take any action over petitions filed against ‘anti-judiciary’ speeches by some political leaders.Justice Naqvi remarked that while Article 19 of the constitution allowed fair criticism of judiciary, not everyone can be permitted to criticise the court decisions just for the sake of exercising their right to criticise. He said that it makes sense for a lawyer or a legal expert only to dwell on the judicial verdicts. Drawing attention to Article 68 of the constitution, Justice Naqvi said it even prevented the parliament from criticizing the judiciary and its decisions. “A person dissatisfied at a verdict should file a review petition,” he added.Stressing that his client was being subjected to baseless criticism, PEMRA counsel Salman Akram Raja said the authority had used its powers to decide on the issue. Observing that PEMRA had dismissed the petition on technical grounds, the bench inquired if the verdict should be taken as a green signal for speeches against the judiciary. PEMRA chose not to stop the ‘anti-judicary’ remarks, said Justice Mehmood.“The authority may have committed a minor mistake by dismissing the petition,” replied Raja. “This is not a minor mistake,” the bench observed. “Instead of taking action, PEMRA sought advice from judiciary. Should publishing of such a notice be considered a minor mistake?”Noting that the notice did not prove the authority had failed in performance of its duties, Justice Jahangir stressed that it was not fulfilling its responsibilities. PEMRA’s counsel admitted that the move was a mistake. Meanwhile, Nawaz Sharif’s counsel AK Dogar again raised objections to the inclusion of Justice Naqvi in the bench. “The judge authored the order against Nawaz Sharif allowing no chance of defence,” the application filed by Dogar reads. It added that the remarks caused stress to his client after which he expects no fair treatment at the hands of Justice Naqvi. However, the bench dismissed the defense counsel’s reservations.

More News

Pakistan moving on ‘right track’: UNGA president

20 Jan, 2019 DailyTimes

UN General Assembly President Maria Fernanda Espinosa Saturday said she has been encouraged to see that the government of Prime Minister Imran Khan is ... Detail

PTI claims differences with PML-Q resolved

20 Jan, 2019 DailyTimes

Punjab Information Minister Fayyazul Hasan Chohan Saturday said the federal and Punjab government have settled all issues with the Pakistan Muslim Lea ... Detail

Hafeez stars as Pakistan beat South Africa in first ODI

20 Jan, 2019 DailyTimes

Imam-ul-Haq and Mohammad Hafeez hit half-centuries as Pakistan cruised to a five-wicket win over South Africa in the first of five matches against Pak ... Detail

Nawaz has ‘unidentified’ symptoms of pain, numbness: medical board

20 Jan, 2019 DailyTimes

Former prime minister Nawaz Sharif has ‘unidentified’ symptoms of pain in his both arms, particularly at night, and numbness of toes, as p ... Detail

Hopes for Taliban talks in Pakistan still alive

20 Jan, 2019 DailyTimes

US peace envoy Zalmay Khalilzad has wrapped up his official talks with top Pakistani civil and military leaders over the past three days but still sta ... Detail

Post Your Comments
Type your Comments / Review in the space below.
Verify Code