Kayani’s ambivalence adversely impacted morale

(Sadia Raza, Islamabad)

Askari Raza Malik

Those were the days when the US was obsessed with pushing Pakistan to ‘do more’. The US was right. Pakistan hesitated. Pakistan was also right.

An American delegation had called on then K-P Governor Awais Ghani. At a point the Americans got frustrated. “Governor, you are not playing straight”. “Are you?”, the Governor replied. The visitor had no answer. At the same time the mutual distrust did not seem to hamper the growing interdependence that served both sides well.

General Musharraf had wholeheartedly thrown his lot with the US ‘War on Terror’ with the exuberance of a soldier. After 9/11 his abrupt U-Turn on Taliban policy and precipitous offensive in Waziristan infuriated the Taliban. Some, not all, turned against Pakistan.

The initial phase of the Allies’ offensive met with spectacular success. The Taliban were in a shambles. The victory seemed only a matter of time. Before the going got tough America had cultivated its own faction of friendly Taliban. Funds poured in for the Taliban from friends and foes alike, all using them to advance their own agendas. Pakistan became a hub of terror. Atrocities inside Pakistan began to assume alarming proportions. Pakistan was being conditioned to own the war on terror as its own contrary to a widespread perception that it was fighting a solely American war. Also the fertile American mind had started to envision the future geopolitical scenario for the region. In this vision the role of India, their newfound love was inevitable. Any role of India in Afghanistan can only be that of a spoiler. India’s consulates at Kandhar and Jalalbad acting as RAW’s outposts to foment trouble in Pakistan is no more a secret. That must have put caution on general Musharraf. Doubt set in and duplicity became diplomacy.

General Aurakzai as the K-P Governor was convinced that the dialogue was the only answer to the problem. He felt confident that he would be able to convert both the Americans and Afghans to his point of view. His soft corner for the Taliban helped them emerge much stronger during his tenure in the province.

All this time the Army stayed in parts of Waziristan and Swat sustaining continued casualties in the absence of firm orders and rules of engagement. General Musharraf’s lassitude and General Kayani’s ambivalence were adversely impacting the Army’s morale. The Army in K-P strongly felt that the loss of men and officers due to emboldened Taliban attacks was aimless and in vain. Even the Corps Commander Peshawar in exasperation was compelled to say that people beyond Attock could not care less as to what was going on in K-P.

Despite this pathetic background when the operations in Swat and South Waziristan were launched in right earnest the Army there responded in its traditional abandon. General Kayani can claim credit for those operations but that is where he ran out of steam. His passive appraisal of extending operations to North Waziristan could not have spurred any civilian leadership into action. When I went to attend the funeral of a child in Peshawar the distraught father had accused Kayani of “criminal inaction for six long years of his tenure as the Army Chief”.

Then came Raheel Sharif. An underdog that he was he must have watched the Army’s policy and operations from the fence, the best place for a cool headed appreciation and rationale deductions. He was there but never a part of the decision making apparatus. He took over with a clear mind with no past baggage to restrain him. Political brick bating and media abuse could not deter him from his resolve. He straightaway went hell for the leather. His sincerity and forthrightness impressed the withdrawing Americans who are left with much fewer options in the region. The Americans, the Afghans, the nation, the whole political elite and now the entire world seem to have put all their money on him.

The December-16 Peshawar mayhem had shaken the nation out of deep slumber and reinvigorated an already committed Raheel Sharif. The domestic and regional landscapes hold promise of a healthy change. The narrative of military antagonists now sounds shallow and toothless. India will have to revise its propaganda themes as well because its past mantra is failing badly.

Now “consolidating the gains of Operation Zarb-e-Azb, considered to be the game changer, is very much important otherwise the vicious cycle of gaining and losing the areas from and to terrorists will continue. The politicians and civil administration will have to rise above the materialistic approach and assist in resettlement of the IDPs and maintaining peace and stability in the area. Let us hope and pray that sacrifices of our Armed Forces bear fruit and peace prevails in the war torn area.”

Raheel Sharif has proved himself to be the game changer. “The nation as a whole, the civil society, media and intelligentsia in particular seem to be at the back of the General. Both the civil and military leaderships, Senate and National or Provincial Assembly emerge out in harmony; the operation extended to Karachi and elsewhere has proved to be successful.” Once the southern part of Punjab is cleaned off the extremist and terrorist elements, the ongoing war against terror will certainly take to its logical end. “Those who know the Chief of Army Staff from close understand well that this was only possible under him.”

(The author is a retired officer from Pakistan Army)

Sadia Raza
About the Author: Sadia Raza Read More Articles by Sadia Raza: 13 Articles with 8468 viewsCurrently, no details found about the author. If you are the author of this Article, Please update or create your Profile here.